Fake claim proves costly for a Richmond resident — February 28
Car crashes remain the number one killer of youth — February 21
Ucluelet man attempts to defraud ICBC — February 8
![]()
Elite Fung of Richmond is facing the consequences of making a fake claim with ICBC. He recently appeared in the Vancouver Provincial Court, where after a two day trial, he was found guilty of providing false information to ICBC, an offence under the Sec 42.1 of the Insurance (Motor Vehicle) Act. He was fined $3500. And ICBC has denied his claim.
"Zero tolerance for fraud is one of ICBC's strategies to help keep rates low and stable," said Steve Tripp, manager of ICBC's Special Investigation Unit. "It is not acceptable to ICBC to sit back and simply pass the cost of fraud onto our customers," said Tripp.
At 2 pm on May 7, 2006, Fung reported to Vancouver Police that his 2004 Mazda RX-8 was stolen from Burrard Street and Nelson Street in Vancouver. However, Richmond RCMP had already recovered Fung's vehicle at 5 am, that same day. The vehicle had been abandoned at Sea Island Way and Miller Road, only three kilometres away from Fung's residence in Richmond. The vehicle was heavily damaged, appearing as though it had crashed into a lamp post. There were no signs of forced entry, ignition damage, or tampering to the vehicle's anti-theft device.
When making his ICBC claim, Fung gave details of his whereabouts on the evening of May 6 and the early morning of May 7, 2006. According to Fung's statement, he also claimed his cellphone was in the vehicle at the time of the theft. As part of ICBC's investigation, a search warrant for Fung's cellphones records was obtained. In reviewing the records, it was determined the cellphone was never stolen. This contributed to the evidence that Fung willfully provided a false statement to ICBC while making his claim.
"ICBC seeks to identify potential fraud before the claim is paid, but also pursues fraudulent claims through civil lawsuits and criminal prosecutions," said Tripp.
ICBC estimates that fraud costs each of ICBC's 3 million policyholders in the range of $100 to $150 per year. The public is encouraged to help fight fraud by reporting suspicious, exaggerated or fraudulent claims. Information provided to ICBC's fraud tips line (604-661-6844 or 1-800-661-6844) is confidential and callers can remain anonymous.
Media Contact:
Doug Henderson,
604-982-1332
![]()
With graduation just around the corner, school hallways are abuzz with anticipation. The last thing on students' minds is the sobering fact that car crashes are the number one killer of youth between the ages of 13 and 21.
To drive home this reality, road safety speaker Cara Johnston-Filler will share her story and the consequences of speeding with many students across the Vancouver Island region. "ICBC wants to educate teens about safe driving and the power of choice," said Brian Sargent, ICBC Road Safety manager, the sponsor of the presentation.
"Speed and alcohol are the top contributing factors in fatal crashes involving young drivers. Thrill-seeking and risk-taking behaviours combined with driver inexperience often play a role," noted Sargent. "Road safety speaker Cara Johnston-Filler gives a compelling and emotionally-charged presentation to remind students to drive responsibly."
Cara watched her identical twin sister, Mairin, die in a speed-related car crash the day after their 18th birthday, during the summer of their graduation from high school. Cara knows what it is like to be young and to think "it'll never happen to me". Cara and Mairin had their whole lives ahead of them. Now, because of someone else's recklessness, Mairin is dead and Cara's life has changed forever. Since two months after her sister's death, Cara has spoken to more than a million students worldwide.
Getting behind the wheel is a risky proposition, young drivers aged 16 to 21 account for eight per cent of all drivers in B.C., but they are involved in 20 per cent of fatal collisions and have more than one and a half times the number of crashes as drivers 22 and over. In 2005, car crashes killed 9 youth and injured around 1,220 in the Vancouver Island area. In BC, there were 76 youth killed and about 9,700 injured during the same time period.
ICBC is working to ensure insurance rates more reflective of the risk each driver presents. Currently, high-risk drivers are not paying enough given the risk they pose on the roads. Charging bad drivers more is one way that ICBC is working to keep rates low and stable for safer drivers.
Cara's 2008 Vancouver Island speaking schedule is attached.
To learn more about road safety speakers and how ICBC is working to keep rates low and stable visit www.icbc.com.
Media Contact:
Tamara McLean,
250 414-7883
Caroline Robinson,
250 729-3518
![]()
John Christopher Majore of Ucluelet is facing the consequences of attempting to defraud ICBC. He recently appeared in Port Alberni Provincial Court, where he pleaded guilty to fraud, an offence under Section 380(1)(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada. He was sentenced to 100 hours community service and two years probation. ICBC has also denied his stolen vehicle claim.
"ICBC has a zero tolerance policy for fraud," said Steve Tripp, ICBC manager Special Investigation Unit. "By combating fraud, ICBC hopes to deter others and recover fraudulent payments, which help to keep rates low and stable for our customers."
On September 15, 2005 Majore purchased insurance for his 1999 Jeep Cherokee. The following day, he reported to police that the Jeep had been stolen. According to the statement he provided ICBC, Majore parked his Jeep on Toquart Bay Road on Friday September 16, 2005 at 11:30 a.m., while he and his girlfriend went into the bush to pick wild mushrooms. They returned approximately six hours later, and discovered the Jeep was gone. The couple decided to hitchhike to Ucluelet to sell their mushrooms and report the theft of the Jeep to the RCMP.
On October 6, 2005, Majore's Jeep was involved in a crash in Ontario. While investigating the crash, the Ontario Provincial Police quickly uncovered the vehicle had been reported stolen in B.C. They questioned the vehicle driver, Robert Broatch, who told police that the vehicle was not stolen but that the owner of the vehicle, Majore, needed money and had given him the Jeep to get rid of.
Majore confessed to ICBC and police that he had tried to get rid of the vehicle so that he could report it stolen and make a false claim. Majore was charged with fraud and had his ICBC claim denied.
Broatch, the driver of the vehicle, was convicted in Ontario Provincial Court of possession of property obtained by crime, Section 354 of the Criminal Code of Canada; dangerous operation of a motor vehicle, Section 249 of the Criminal Code of Canada; and failure to stop at the scene of an accident, Section 252 of the Criminal Code of Canada. Broatch received an eight month conditional sentence, followed by 12 months probation and is prohibited from driving for two years.
"Insurance fraud is not a victimless crime, it affects everyone's insurance rates", said Tripp. "That's why we invest in more fraud prevention and investigation than most property and casualty insurance companies in Canada".
Customers are encouraged to do their part to help fight fraud by reporting suspicious, exaggerated or fraudulent claims. Information provided to ICBC's fraud tips line (604-661-6844 or 1-800-661-6844) is confidential and callers can remain anonymous.